Competitive Analysis
Please select a competitor from below to compare systems. Competitive analysis is based on website
information and has not been
confirmed with the manufacturers. Specifications are subject to change without notice.
| Company |
| System |
| Features |
| MSHA Part 23 Approval |
| Network Architecture |
| Tracking Technology |
| Tracking Accuracy |
| Direction of Travel Capability |
| Does Device Build Mesh Network? |
| Voice Communications |
| Text Communications |
| InSeT Systems |
| Inertial Sensor Tracking and Communications Systems |
| Miner Tracker |
| Pending |
| 900MHz mesh network w/optional fiber optics to surface |
| Inertial Navigation |
| 25 feet after 24 hours of use |
| Yes |
| Yes |
| Store & Forward with acknowledge |
| Yes |


-
| Active Control Technology |
| Active Mine System |
| Wireless WiFi Phone |
| Approved |
| 2.4GHZ wirless network |
| RFID |
| 1/2 the distance between access nodes |
| No |
| No |
| Real time with no acknowledge |
| Yes |
-
| American Mine Research |
| Tagging and Tracking System |
| Messenger |
| Approved |
| UHF from Messenger to Reader and Wire or fiber between Readers and to surface |
| RFID |
| 1/2 the distance between Smart Readers |
| No |
| No |
| No |
| Yes |
-
| L-3 Communications |
| Accolade System |
| Miner Mesh Radio (MMR) |
| Approved |
| 900 MHz mesh network w/existing leaky feeder or Ehernet to surface |
| Reverse RFID w/RSSI |
| 1/2 the distance between fixed mesh nodes |
| No |
| No |
| Real Time with no acknowledge |
| No |
-
| Matrix Design Group |
| METS |
| RFID Tags |
| Approved |
| Coaxil cable network between readers; wired or fiber to surface |
| RFID |
| 1/2 the distance between smart antenna readers |
| No |
| No |
| No |
| No |
-
| Mine Site Technologies |
| Impact System |
| Tracker Tagging / Impact VOIP |
| Approved / Approved |
| 2.4GHZ network with wire or fiber between WLAN's and to surface |
| RFID / RFID |
| 1/2 the distance between nodes / 1/2 the distance between Impact WLANs |
| No / No |
| No / No |
| No / Real time with no acknowledge |
| No / Yes |
-
| Northern Lights Technology |
| Digital Communications System |
| Voice over WiFi |
| Approved |
| 2.4GHz network w/ fiber (Ethernet) to surface |
| RFID |
| 1/2 the distance between access nodes |
| No |
| No |
| Real time with no acknowledge |
| Yes |
-
| Tunnel Radio of America |
| MineAx System |
| Mine Ax Bird Dog Tracker / Ultra Comm/ Motorola Handheld |
| Approved |
| UHF to readers; leaky feeder between readers and to surface |
| RFID / None |
| 1/2 the distance between readers / N/A |
| No / N/A |
| No / No |
| No / Real time with no acknowledge |
| No / No |
-
| Varis Mine Technology |
| Smart Tag System |
| Smart Tag |
| Approved |
| Coaxial antenna between tags and readers; fiber or leaky feeder between readers and to surface |
| RFID |
| 1/2 the distance between readers |
| No |
| No |
| No |
| No |
-
| Venture Design Services |
| Mine Tracer System |
| Mine Tracer Mobile Tag (MC) / Text Messaging Mobile Communicator (TMC) |
| Approved / Pending |
| 400 MHz point-to-point network with cabling between wireless access points and subnet controller and cabling to
surface |
| RFID / RFID |
| 1/2 the distance between wireless access points / 1/2 the distance between wireless access points |
| No / No |
| No / No |
| No / No |
| No / Yes |
"Our goal is to greatly improve the chances that underground miners can go home to their families every day when their work is done."